HASA Stories

Comments for: Pelargir

Talk to Dwimordene

If you are a HASA member, you must login to submit a comment.

We're sorry. Only HASA members may post comments. If you would like to speak with the author, please use the "Email Author" button in the Reader Toolbox. If you would like to join HASA, click here. Membership is free.

2 Comments

 
 

Pelargir

ecrm - 06 Dec 10 - 11:18 AM

General Comment

I agree with you that Pelargir is one of the great mysteries of Lord of the Rings, however there are some clues as to what may have happened.

1. Amoung the men arriving in Minas Tirith with Imrahil were some men spared from the ships. Obviously Gondor realised that its small fleet would not be able to compete with the men of Umbar. However the fact that these men were sent tells us one of two things;

a. Pelargir sent them on because they realised there was no hope of defending the city.

b. They were sent because Pelargir was already well manned by local levies and could spare the men.

I personally favour b, as I don't belive the inhabitants would give up the city without a fight.

We should also pause to consider the city's likely defences. These were probably formidable; even if they weren't the old Numenorean walls which may have been damaged in the downfall the walls were almost certainly the ones which held off the army of Eldacar for a whole year until 1448.

Secondly the city itself would very probably have been defended from attack from the south using a metal chain with large wooden blocks. It would not have been beyond the craft of either Numenor or Gondor to make. Breaking a boom of this nature is difficult, made almost impossible by the flow of a river current. The only way to capture it would be to land and destroy the capstan heads which would certainly have been inside the walls.

My own feeling is that by the time Aragorn arrived the outer defences, including the capstans had almost certainly fallen. This would have allowed the corsairs to sail into the city and capture a large part of it. However I would be surprised if a city like Pelargir had not taken this eventuality into account. My guess is that there would have been an inner set of walls and inncer city which was not so vulnerable to being bypassed by the ships. Their fall was inevitable owing to the weight of the corsairs numbers, but might not have occurred by the time that Aragorn arrived.

Go to Pelargir

Pelargir

Dwimordene - 06 Dec 10 - 7:22 PM

General Comment

Ooh, thank you ecrm! Good points! 

I'm not well-informed on siege warfare on land or by water, so between that gap and the fact that what happens inside Pelargir is what interests me more, I've been avoiding writing about specific defenses.

But I agree that as Tolkien wrote it, it seems as thought the city had been only partially subdued by the time the Grey Company and the Army of the Dead reached it. There would be survivors, but different areas of the city might have fared more or less well. 

If I could impose on you, though: where did you find the reference to Pelargirite sailors brought by Imrahil to Minas Tirith? I could've sworn I'd found all the tallies of people who came to the city - either in the initial defense muster or else with Aragorn later, in one of two waves. But I can't find the passage you're referring to. There's the note that "fisher-folk of the Ethir, some hundred or more spared from the ships" came to Minas Tirith in the first muster, but they didn't come with Imrahil and there's no specific reference to Pelargir, though I suppose it could be inferred that they would have answered to Pelargir. It just seemed to me, when reading it, that Tolkien could've said so if he'd intended them to be the contribution from that city, since he was intent on listing everyone's province and lord so specifically. 

Anyhow, though, excellent food for thought! Thanks very much!

Dwim

Go to Pelargir

In Stories

Finding Story Comments

Only chapters with comments appear in the drop down list. "General Comments" are free floating and don't belong to a particular chapter.

To leave a comment for a chapter that doesn't appear in the drop-down list, go to that chapter and use the form on the page.

Donation Options

Keyword Search

Search story summaries and titles


Don't use commas. Separate words with spaces.