HASA Stories

Comments for: Full of Wisdom and Perfect in Beauty

Talk to Maeve Riannon

If you are a HASA member, you must login to submit a comment.

We're sorry. Only HASA members may post comments. If you would like to speak with the author, please use the "Email Author" button in the Reader Toolbox. If you would like to join HASA, click here. Membership is free.

2 Comments

 
 

Full of Wisdom and Perfect in Beauty

Aganaphel - 04 Apr 07 - 1:16 PM

Ch. 5: A Slip

Interesting new chapter, Maeve.

I like how you portray Gimilzor. It was foolish to marry Inzilbeth in the first place, it was foolish to leave her son with her. I really can't see what he DID gain by marrying a Faithful? Strange that he realized all that too late.

Also remarkable that he had a prophetic vision - his Kingly blood allows for that, it seems, despite his rejection of the old religion.

I also loved your brief insight into the Numenorean religious doctrine. The story of the crown of the Holy Melkor is even poetic!

But there I have a question: Why is Melkor "king of Armenelos?" Why not "King of Arda" or "King of the World" or something?

Thank you for posting. I am awaiting more updates!

Aganaphel

Go to Full of Wisdom and Perfect in Beauty

Full of Wisdom and Perfect in Beauty

Maeve Riannon - 04 Apr 07 - 3:12 PM

Ch. 5: A Slip

Once again, thanks for your insighted (does this word exist??) review!

 I really can't see what he DID gain by marrying a Faithful?

Well, back when he did it it was just the right manouevre to perform at the right time. He felt that his predecessors had left the Faithful largely unsupervised in the East and that they had grown strong, and his ambitious project consisted in pretending an alliance, "restoring" them to their old honours, and therefore forcing them to spend alternate years in Armenelos and leave family at the capital at all times (this was the system in absolute monarchies of many countries, and for that same reason: to prevent nobles from plotting treason). And, what was even more important: with this appearance of favour, he tore Eärendur away from his followers, who remained in the East.

His marriage to Inzilbêth was a mere pretext, the "facade" to do all this, because political decisions that are taken against a long tradition of contrary decisions must be sealed and justified. And it turned out well enough- but the tragedy of Paranoid Gimilzôr is that there is always something that he cannot control.

Same as for leaving his son with her - I think that Gimilzôr (who is quite young- as a ruler, at least) is, once again, believing that he can control everything, while in fact he cannot. I do not think he would have taken his heir away from his mother at birth, for no reason at all, against custom and tradition, and on plus cause a scandal, but still, the boy was far from being "left" with his mother either: the chapter shows that he spends most of the day with tutors and guardians that his father has chosen, and is just supposed to come and visit her once in a while. That a random tale told to a child could outweight hours and hours of "indoctrination" - this was not so obvious for him at the time. (And I think he was basically right, in a sense: the boy might have mentioned the wrong name and sent all his instinctive alarms flaring, but it´s clear enough throughout the conversation that if there´s something he knows well, it´s still the King´s religion. )

But there I have a question: Why is Melkor "king of Armenelos?"

Because in the religion I am recreating here, the god is deeply connected with the city. This means that he is defined as the "protector" god of a collectivity in opposition to others. He is *not* the god of others, he is the god of the Númenoreans. He may defeat and enslave the gods of other peoples, but he can never establish this relationship of protection with a stranger. If he became "King of the World", it would mean that the Númenoreans do not have any special right to his favour, and this would ruin the relationship between the god and his people. (This is not so weird: it was exactly the same story with the God of Israel. In fact, in Men´s history, universal gods are rather rare.).

As for why Armenelos and not Númenor, you might ask: The main atribute of the god I am recreating is his symbiotic relationship with royalty. He is the King´s divinisation; the King is his representative in the world of mortals and he is the King´s representative in the immortal plane. The fact that he lives in the capital, which is the King´s dwelling-place and centre of power, is just a way to underline this. But there will be a lot more of Melkor in this fic, as you may imagine.  :)

 Oops Embarassed- this was way too long. Thanks for your attentive reading, as always!

Go to Full of Wisdom and Perfect in Beauty

In Stories

Finding Story Comments

Only chapters with comments appear in the drop down list. "General Comments" are free floating and don't belong to a particular chapter.

To leave a comment for a chapter that doesn't appear in the drop-down list, go to that chapter and use the form on the page.

Donation Options

Keyword Search

Search story summaries and titles


Don't use commas. Separate words with spaces.