HASA Stories

Comments for: Lighting Fires

Talk to Gwynnyd

If you are a HASA member, you must login to submit a comment.

We're sorry. Only HASA members may post comments. If you would like to speak with the author, please use the "Email Author" button in the Reader Toolbox. If you would like to join HASA, click here. Membership is free.

5 Comments

 
 

Lighting Fires

Meril - 07 Sep 06 - 5:39 PM

General Comment

*squeal*  Gwynnyd, this is absolutely perfect! It has just the right mixture of seriousness and humor. 

For whatever reason (probably the elves in my head), I've never thought about young Estel, but the way he is totally unaware of his heritage (which I knew, but didn't really think about) is so wonderful.  "I thought I was going to hunt orcs with you when I grew up..."  Growing up so misplaced, and as such an oddity among the Rivendell elves, gives him this very unique perspective among Men. 

"I don't know any men."  This was the single sentence that really made me feel how lonely Estel's life was, and just how sheltered he was from... well, from everything.

This was an absolute delight to read.  (And it's the birthday that keeps on giving that's the best kind, after all! :D)

*hugs* Thank you!  

Go to Lighting Fires

Lighting Fires

Gwynnyd - 07 Sep 06 - 6:29 PM

General Comment

I'm so glad you liked it!

Happy Birthday, six months late!  LOL 

Gwynnyd 

Go to Lighting Fires

Lighting Fires

Calenharn - 05 Nov 06 - 6:58 PM

General Comment

My comments pertain to the story as a whole.

I am not particularly crazy about young Estel (or, for that matter, young Legolas) stories, but I found this one to be both charming and thought provoking.   Although it started out as a story about Estel the reluctant student (of history, of mathematics, of anything academic), it really is a story about Estel the novice Ranger, and his first "experience" in survival (and warfare) in the Wild (and the lessons learned therein).

It was very canonical and in character for Estel the young boy to get this first training from his foster brother.   (Who else but the family of Elrond to train him, and who better than an older brother who he must have hero-worshiped?)  What made the story special was not that the training was yet another thing on Elrond's checklist, but was something that Estel (effectively) demanded for himself.   I rather liked the idea that even Elrond could make mistakes (in judging Estel's maturity, and the course that his studies should take).

Another bit that I liked was Elrohir's quandry in trying to justify the necessity of the academic studies to Estel, without revealing *why* they were necessary.   I thought that detail really added to the story, and that Elrohir came up with a good explanation.

Finally, I really enjoyed the physical description of their foray into the "Wild".

Well done.

Go to Lighting Fires

Lighting Fires

TariElfLady - 10 Apr 07 - 10:17 AM

Ch. 7: Author's Notes

This tale was a pure delight to read.  Smile

It would seem to me that Estel thought of himself as more Elf than Man.  The Elves were pratically the only beings he knew.  It must have been hard not to be able to do everything they did.

Elves truly exists in my mind, and I'd love to join them.

Tari 

Go to Lighting Fires

Lighting Fires

Gwynnyd - 10 Apr 07 - 4:39 PM

Ch. 7: Author's Notes

Thank you!  I imagine that it would be fairly easy for Elrond et al to forget that Estel did not have the background of all the other fosterlings.  Estel probably did think of himself as an Elf and not a Man when he was a child. How would he know how men were different, after all?

Gwynnyd 

Go to Lighting Fires

In Stories

Finding Story Comments

Only chapters with comments appear in the drop down list. "General Comments" are free floating and don't belong to a particular chapter.

To leave a comment for a chapter that doesn't appear in the drop-down list, go to that chapter and use the form on the page.

Donation Options

Keyword Search

Search story summaries and titles


Don't use commas. Separate words with spaces.