Comments for: No Man's Child
Talk to Anoriath
If you are a HASA member, you must login to submit a comment.
We're sorry. Only HASA members may post comments. If you would like to speak with the author, please use the "Email Author" button in the Reader Toolbox. If you would like to join HASA, click here. Membership is free.
4 Comments
No Man's Child
Gandalfs apprentice - 16 Sep 06 - 5:58 AM
Anoriath:
Again, beautiful and sad. You are a very gifted writer. Your use of the mythology here--Huan and Beren--is so well done, I am in awe.
One niggly thing: Missing a word in "How do find Halbarad?"
Go to No Man's Child
No Man's Child
Anoriath - 16 Sep 06 - 12:14 PM
One niggly thing: Missing a word in "How do find Halbarad?"
LOL! *face-palm* You have no idea how many times I read that passage... and still didn't pick up on that. Funny how our brains work. I hear that professional proof-readers read the material backwards. With good reason, I suppose, but it sounds like rather a tortured experience.
Your use of the mythology here--Huan and Beren--is so well done
Thanks, GA. The parallels begged to be brought to life. :o)
Go to No Man's Child
No Man's Child
Dwimordene - 23 Jun 07 - 9:38 PM
Gently slips the rhetorical knife in, and then there comes the fatal twist at the end. I wouldn't be Nienelen for the world.
Dwim
Go to No Man's Child
No Man's Child
Anoriath - 24 Jun 07 - 8:01 AM
Gently slips the rhetorical knife in, and then there comes the fatal twist at the end. I wouldn't be Nienelen for the world.
Dwim
No, not a comfortable position at all, but one full of compromises that pit the heart against the head. That tension has so much potential in it to explore human relationships and character development.
I'm so tickled you're reading, particularly as it was this passage:
"I have been asked if there was no one at all that I would get a child on, in or out of marriage."
and
"Gilraen never remarried, nor shall she ever: she loved my father so. And though for long I knew nothing more of Arathorn than that, have you any idea of what that means to a lad? I would be to the mother of my children what my father was to my mother, and I cannot see myself as able to do that if it is a union, or even a marriage, only in order to get heirs."
that bit me about the ankles and made me write No Man's Child. I don't suppose it sounds familiar, does it? :D
Thanks Dwim.
~Silli
Go to No Man's Child