Discussing: Question on Calendars
Question on Calendars
Message: 41775
23 May 05 3:00 PM
Original Post
General Audience
Read-Only
Loremaster
Re: Question on Calendars
Re: Question on Calendars
Re: Question on Calendars
Re: Question on Calendars
Re: Question on Calendars
Re: Question on Calendars
Re: Question on Calendars
Thank you for all the helpful information clearly presented. However, I think Tolkein basically contradicts himself and I'm not sure it makes sense that March 25, 3019 was the first day of the new year. Two reasons:
1) ROTK appendix D says that "the New Reckoning was begun in the Restored Kingdom in T.A. 3019," so that only means that the New Reckoning was adopted some time that year and
2) On March 25, 3019 the battle is raging outside the Black Gate. Who is going to declare it a new year?
*Big edit of my earlier comment*
So it is possible they started celebrating the mid-year days in September, 3019, but that does not really seem logical (because they would celebrate the New Year on March 24/35 3020 even though the year actually changed in December...), though it seems supported by the earlier quote. Here is what makes more sense:
In Appendix D it says "for purposes of record in the Kingdom Fourth Age 1 was the year that began according to the New Reckoning in March 25, 3021 old style." I interpret this to mean that 3021 was a short year, and probably that Mettare/Yestare were celebrated at the end of 3020, and three months later in March 3021 T.A./1 F.A (unless Elessar saw changing the mid-year and calendar reform in general as essential to establishing his legitimacy or the stability of the realm, which I doubt, but is not without precedence, e.g. French or Russian revolutions.)
So, unless anyone wants to talk me out of it, I am going to assume that the calendar reform did not actually go into effect until 3021.
-Raihon