HASA Forums

On Our Minds

Narya, Nenya, and Vilya

Posted On: 05/16/12 7:46 PM
By: MlleGigi
In: Prospective Challenges

Maybe I'm just very slow on the uptake...but after some thirty-five years as a Tolkien fan, it only hit me a moment ago that each of the Three Rings seems to have bestowed a particular talent on the person who wields it which is in some way related to the element supposedly governed by that ring.  Narya, the Ring of Fire, has evidently given Gandalf a gift for what might be called pyromancy -- whether in self-defense (such as the flames he uses to defend both Thorin and Company and later the Fellowship from Wargs) or as entertainment (in the form of smoke-rings or fireworks).  Nenya, the Ring of Water, has granted Galadriel the ability to use her Mirror as a scrying glass.  So in what unique way(s) does Vilya, the Ring of Air, give Elrond power over the air?  Tolkien didn't explain...but since he did see fit to tell us that Vilya is the most powerful of the Three, it seems only natural to presume that it would have made Elrond skilled with using air in some way much as Narya and Nenya have made Gandalf and Galadriel skilled with using fire and water.

I hereby invite anyone who's inclined to take up this challenge and come up with a potential answer to this question -- preferably one which is not too far-fetched or ridiculous, if you please (although the fact nevertheless remains that Gandalf sometimes puts his powers over fire to somewhat trivial use!)

RECORD EDITED BY ANGLACHEL - I removed the icons and promotions code from this post. MlleGigi, please don't post crappy spam buttons and potentially malicious code into HASA's forums system. Do it again and you are permanently banned from the site.

Go to Thread

Re: Challenge Entries

Posted On: 05/15/12 6:07 AM
By: Linaewen
In: Challenges Fundraiser

My entry is posted for the challenge -- Hoarded History, a story written for the "Oh, the Library" nûzgul!

Go to Thread

Re: Challenge Entries

Posted On: 05/14/12 2:28 PM
By: Aruthir
In: Challenges Fundraiser

I have posted a third story in this challenge- "The Last Page"- and hope you guys enjoy it. Or at the very least read it.

Go to Thread

Re: Story Pledge Challenge

Posted On: 05/13/12 3:32 AM
By: Nath
In: Challenges Fundraiser

Hi maeglin,

Interesting idea... I'll see if the Muse will bite...

Go to Thread

Re: Challenge Pledges

Posted On: 05/12/12 10:37 PM
By: Linaewen
In: Challenges Fundraiser

In addition to supplying an entry for the challenge (which is beginning to take shape at last!), I am pledging $2 per story up to a total of $20 -- this includes the stories already written plus any stories forthcoming.  Grin  Sorry I can't do more at the moment!

Go to Thread

Re: Challenge Pledges

Posted On: 05/12/12 10:24 PM
By: maeglin
In: Challenges Fundraiser

Hi.  From May 11th on

Go to Thread

Re: Challenge Pledges

Posted On: 05/12/12 7:40 PM
By: Anglachel
In: Challenges Fundraiser

Thanks for the pledge, maeglin. Are you pledging for stories written after May 11th, or for all stories in the challenge? Your pledge isn't quite clear.

Thanks!

Anglachel

Go to Thread

Re: Challenge Entries

Posted On: 05/12/12 7:38 PM
By: Anglachel
In: Challenges Fundraiser

Most excellent, Aruthir! Consider yourself "absolved." Wink

OK, we have two other authors (Linaewen & RiverOtter) who are working on stories - who else will step up to the challenge?

Anglachel

Go to Thread

Re: May 2012 Birthday Cards

Posted On: 05/12/12 6:17 PM
By: RiverOtter
In: 2012 - HASA Birthdays

My birthday was on the 6th. I would like something about writing or paper.

Go to Thread

Re: Challenge Entries

Posted On: 05/12/12 1:53 PM
By: Aruthir
In: Challenges Fundraiser

My Muses have seen fit to grace me with another story for this Challenge- "Happily Ever After". Please let me know what you think?

Go to Thread

In Forums

Most Recent Forum Posts

These are the ten most recent messages posted to the Forums. Only posts in discussions open to all HASA members are shown.

Click on the headings to expand or collapse the message. This is useful to close up topics you are not interested in reading.

For a complete list of discussions that have been updated in the last 30 days, please go to the 1 Month of Posts page.